View Issue Details

This issue affects 1 person(s).
 10
IDProjectCategoryView StatusLast Update
04104Bug reportsSurvey takingpublic2010-06-08 21:51
Reporterleolime Assigned Totexens  
PrioritynormalSeverityminor 
Status closedResolutionwon't fix 
Product Version1.87+ 
Summary04104: Checkbox for Other is missing
Description

Question type: Multiple options with comment
Option 'Other' set to YES
added 7 answers (but I guess, this is not really relevant)

Two issues:

1) The checkbox is missing ==> I guess this might get a problem when running statistics
2) ':' is added at the end of the text. instead of
'Sonstige:' Angabe möglich:
appears
'Sonstige:' Angabe möglich::

TagsNo tags attached.
Attached Files
limesurvey_sample_81995.csv (5,735 bytes)   
# LimeSurvey Survey Dump
# DBVersion 142
# This is a dumped survey from the LimeSurvey Script
# http://www.limesurvey.org/
# Do not change this header!

#
# SURVEYS TABLE
#
"sid","owner_id","admin","active","expires","startdate","adminemail","private","faxto","format","template","language","additional_languages","datestamp","usecookie","notification","allowregister","allowsave","autonumber_start","autoredirect","allowprev","printanswers","ipaddr","refurl","datecreated","publicstatistics","publicgraphs","listpublic","htmlemail","tokenanswerspersistence","assessments","usecaptcha","usetokens","bounce_email","attributedescriptions","emailresponseto","tokenlength"
"81995","1","LeO NoWhere","N","","","leo_08_15@fantasymail.de","Y","","G","default","de-informal","","N","N","0","N","Y","0","N","Y","N","N","N","2010-02-07","N","N","N","Y","N","N","D","N","leo_08_15@fantasymail.de","","","15"

#
# GROUPS TABLE
#
"gid","sid","group_name","group_order","description","language"
"19","81995","Sample Group1","0","","de-informal"

#
# QUESTIONS TABLE
#
"qid","sid","gid","type","title","question","preg","help","other","mandatory","lid","lid1","question_order","language"
"52","81995","19","L","Like","How much do you like LimeSurvey?<br />","","","N","N","0","0","0","de-informal"
"53","81995","19","P","Option","What to change?<br />","","","Y","N","0","0","1","de-informal"

#
# ANSWERS TABLE
#
"qid","code","answer","default_value","assessment_value","sortorder","language"
"53","impr1","Better support","N","0","1","de-informal"
"53","impr2","quicker Bugfixing","N","0","2","de-informal"
"53","impr3","no fu**ing samples","N","0","3","de-informal"
"53","impr4","consistent GUI for reorder (Questions, Labels, Question Group)","N","0","4","de-informal"
"52","like1","Very much","N","0","1","de-informal"
"52","like2","much","N","0","2","de-informal"
"52","like3","acceptable","N","0","3","de-informal"
"52","like4","dislike","N","0","5","de-informal"
"52","like5","not really","N","0","4","de-informal"

#
# CONDITIONS TABLE
#
"cid","qid","scenario","cqid","cfieldname","method","value"
"41","53","1","52","81995X19X52","!=","like4"
"42","53","1","52","81995X19X52","!="," "

#
# LABELSETS TABLE
#

#
# LABELS TABLE
#

#
# QUESTION_ATTRIBUTES TABLE
#
"qaid","qid","attribute","value"
"556","52","display_columns","1"
"555","52","alphasort","0"
"563","52","public_statistics","0"
"562","52","page_break","0"
"561","52","other_replace_text",""
"560","52","other_numbers_only","0"
"559","52","other_comment_mandatory","0"
"558","52","hidden","0"
"557","52","hide_tip","0"
"564","52","random_order","0"
"565","52","scale_export","0"
"566","53","array_filter",""
"567","53","array_filter_exclude",""
"568","53","hide_tip","0"
"569","53","hidden","0"
"570","53","max_answers",""
"571","53","min_answers",""
"572","53","other_comment_mandatory","0"
"573","53","other_numbers_only","0"
"574","53","other_replace_text",""
"575","53","page_break","0"
"576","53","public_statistics","0"
"577","53","random_order","0"
"578","53","scale_export","0"

#
# ASSESSMENTS TABLE
#

#
# SURVEYS_LANGUAGESETTINGS TABLE
#
"surveyls_survey_id","surveyls_language","surveyls_title","surveyls_description","surveyls_welcometext","surveyls_endtext","surveyls_url","surveyls_urldescription","surveyls_email_invite_subj","surveyls_email_invite","surveyls_email_remind_subj","surveyls_email_remind","surveyls_email_register_subj","surveyls_email_register","surveyls_email_confirm_subj","surveyls_email_confirm","surveyls_dateformat"
"81995","de-informal","sample survey","","","<br />","","","Einladung zur Teilnahme an einer Umfrage","Hallo {FIRSTNAME},<br /><br />Hiermit möchten wir Dich zu einer Umfrage einladen.<br /><br />Der Titel der Umfrage ist <br />'{SURVEYNAME}'<br /><br />'{SURVEYDESCRIPTION}'nnUm an dieser Umfrage teilzunehmen, klicke bitte auf den unten stehenden Link.nn Mit freundlichen Grüßen,<br /><br />{ADMINNAME} ({ADMINEMAIL})<br /><br />----------------------------------------------<br />Klicken hier um die Umfrage zu starten:<br />{SURVEYURL}","Erinnerung an die Teilnahme an einer Umfrage","Hallo {FIRSTNAME},<br /><br />Vor kurzem haben wir Dich zu einer Umfrage eingeladen.<br /><br />Zu unserem Bedauern haben wir bemerkt, dass Du die Umfrage noch nicht ausgefüllt hast. Wir möchten Dir mitteilen, dass die Umfrage noch aktiv ist und würden uns freuen, wenn Du teilnehmen könntest.<br /><br />Der Titel der Umfrage ist <br />'{SURVEYNAME}'<br /><br />'{SURVEYDESCRIPTION}'<br /><br />Um an dieser Umfrage teilzunehmen, klicke bitte auf den unten stehenden Link.<br /><br /> Mit freundlichen Grüßen,<br /><br />{ADMINNAME} ({ADMINEMAIL})<br /><br />----------------------------------------------<br />Klicken Du hier um die Umfrage zu starten:<br />{SURVEYURL}","Registrierungsbestätigung für Teilnahmeumfrage","Hallo {FIRSTNAME},<br /><br />Du (oder jemand, der Deine Email benutzt hat) hat sich für eine Umfrage mit dem Titel {SURVEYNAME} angemeldet.<br /><br />Um an dieser Umfrage teilzunehmen, klicke bitte auf den folgenden Link.nn{SURVEYURL}<br /><br />Wenn Du irgendwelche Fragen zu dieser Umfrage hast oder wenn Du Dich _nicht_ für diese Umfrage angemeldet hast und Du glaubst, dass Dir diese Email irrtümlicherweise zugeschickt worden ist, kontaktiere bitte {ADMINNAME} unter {ADMINEMAIL}.","Abschlussbestätigung einer Umfrage","Hallo {FIRSTNAME},nnVielen Dank für die Teilnahme an der Umfrage mit dem Titel {SURVEYNAME}. Deine Antworten wurden bei uns gespeichert.nnWenn Du irgendwelche Fragen zu dieser Email hast, kontaktiere mich bitte {ADMINNAME} unter {ADMINEMAIL}.nnMit freundlichen Grüßen,nn{ADMINNAME}","1"

#
# QUOTA TABLE
#

#
# QUOTA_MEMBERS TABLE
#

#
# QUOTA_LANGUAGESETTINGS TABLE
#

limesurvey_sample_81995.csv (5,735 bytes)   
ScreenShot014.jpg (13,771 bytes)   
ScreenShot014.jpg (13,771 bytes)   
ScreenShot015.jpg (37,228 bytes)   
ScreenShot015.jpg (37,228 bytes)   
bug04104-2.png (18,864 bytes)   
bug04104-2.png (18,864 bytes)   
bug-4104-other.png (84,208 bytes)   
bug-4104-other.png (84,208 bytes)   
bug4104-other-details.png (99,011 bytes)   
bug4104-other-details.png (99,011 bytes)   
Bug heat10
Complete LimeSurvey version number (& build)8243
I will donate to the project if issue is resolved
Browser
Database type & versionMySQL 5
Server OS (if known)Linux
Webserver software & version (if known)Apache
PHP Version5.2
Git branch / Pull Request URL

Users monitoring this issue

There are no users monitoring this issue.

Activities

user372

2010-02-06 22:54

  ~11001

Please add a screenshot and a simple sample survey (survey structure as .csv-file), where we can reproduce the issue - THX!

leolime

leolime

2010-02-10 08:19

reporter   ~11025

Since the status is stell on feedback, is there something more missing?

c_schmitz

c_schmitz

2010-02-10 10:07

administrator   ~11029

Yes, a screenshot.

leolime

leolime

2010-02-10 14:52

reporter   ~11031

014.jpg is from the Dataentry screen from survey, 015 is from the Survey in Runtime.

Mazi

Mazi

2010-05-14 14:06

updater   ~11819

Texens, can you check if you can reproduce the problem?

texens

texens

2010-05-16 00:35

reporter   ~11820

Confirmed, We have two textboxes instead of a checkbox and a single textbox.
But, there is just one colon (as in the screenshot above - bug04104-2.png).

leolime, could you please elaborate on the colon thingy?

Thanks

Mazi

Mazi

2010-05-16 12:50

updater   ~11822

I don't think that "1) The checkbox is missing" is a bug but intended behavior. I checked at an older 1.86 version and it is the same there.
You probably don't need the "other" checkbox. It should count as "answer given" if the first text field is filled out. Please check the behavior when running statistics.

texens

texens

2010-05-16 15:31

reporter   ~11823

Mazi,
But, why do we have two textboxes for the other field (see screenshot)? Its a bit confusing to have two textboxes where just one would suffice. Maybe we can do away with that extra redundant textbox.

Mazi

Mazi

2010-05-16 16:34

updater   ~11824

I think it's to define an answer at the first field (like at radio questions having the "other" option) and add a text at the second field.

Please contact Thibault about the details, I can't only guess if this is intended behavior.
Also please chexck if statistics work correctly for this question type.

leolime

leolime

2010-05-17 10:36

reporter   ~11826

I would prefer to split the discussion into

1) What would a user expect?
2) Is it worth the effort to fix it?

IMHO mixing both might loose the point, as well as a discussion about 'Was it there and if yes, then its not a bug'. And guessing about the intention of the developer who once coded it. As an end user I have some expectiations, and to be honest I do NOT check them with the developer who once coded the stuff.

My expectation is as mentioned when I raised the ticket, i.e. one checkbox with the same Layout as the above answers and only one input-field. I am happy to read texens comment about similar expectation of the user interface.

I would see the next step for validation, if it is possible to do it that way or not. resp. how much effort. I could live as well with the statement 'fix should look like ... but we do not have the ressource to fix it....'...

Mixing developer-efforts with user expectations is something I would not like to discuss. Too much engery waste for flames. Closing it immediately would make the same result, but saving engery.

Mazi

Mazi

2010-05-17 11:33

updater   ~11828

"My expectation is ... one checkbox with the same Layout as the above answers and only one input-field."
This would be the result when having a multiple choice question with an "other" option" where you don't have any comment text fields. At the "multiple options with comments" question type you always have an additional comment field for each item and when enabling the other option you have the opportunity (like at the "common" multiple choice question) to define your own item by entering a text. So having a text field for your own item plus a comment text field is the way it should work.
I agree that having a checkbox for the additional item would make things more clear instead of just filling in an item but all he other code (export, viewing results, editing data, data entry,...) is based on the current layout without an additional checkbox so I vote for not changing this, the effort would be huge.
Only further issue to look at is how statistics deal with that additional item (does it have it's own bar at the chart?). Can anybody test and provide a screenshot?

leolime

leolime

2010-05-17 12:21

reporter   ~11831

I know, this is not the discussion forum, therefore I keep it short and would like to go back to the issue as it was raised: The checkbox is missing! The rest, I could live with, more or less...

'I agree that having a checkbox for the additional item would make things more clear instead of just filling in an item'
Great ==> i.e. confirmed.

'but ... ' why a 'but'? The one does not mix with the other, i.e. it makes me confused to argue what I should expect and argued about the the efforts. If the efforts are too high ==> low priority...

About the efforts, I do not understand, why not make a dummy-checkbox there, which maintains the current behaviour, but ignores the result?

Agreed as well that the impact might be on the results in the DB. So, what kind of test resp. screenshot are you looking for? Details?

Mazi

Mazi

2010-05-17 12:37

updater   ~11832

When adding a dummy checkbox there is the problem when using back/next buttons -> the checkbox won't be checked when switching through pages, it also has to be coded.
In general I vote for leaving everything as is.

Can you provide a screenshot of admin statistic showing the table overview and bar chart of this question.

texens

texens

2010-05-22 22:04

reporter   ~11946

The statistics is working fine. (see screenshots)
Clicking on the "other" lands on a page that shows the comments attached to the other field. Note that this page does not actually show the item for which this comment was given. For example, to the question - "which of these is your favourite movie?", one may enter the item : "The Dark Knight", and give the comment - "the action is awesome". In this case, the comment i.e. "the action is awesome" will be displayed, but the item i.e. "The Dark Knight" itself won't be displayed.
Though, clicking on the response Id just to the left of the comment(encircled in black on the screenshot-bug4104-other), lands to the browse Individual response page(screenshot - bug4104-other-details), where one can see the item corresponding to this comment.
So, the statistics is working fine.
A dummy checkbox can be added, but will call for adding conditions to the fieldmap creation and a couple other places. I'm not sure if its worth the effort. I'll try giving it a shot when I have the time, but closing it as won't fix for the time being.

Issue History

Date Modified Username Field Change
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime New Issue
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime Status new => assigned
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime Assigned To => user372
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime LimeSurvey build number => 8243
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime Database & DB-Version => MySQL 5
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime Operating System (Server) => Linux
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime Webserver => Apache
2010-02-06 19:52 leolime PHP Version => 5.2
2010-02-06 22:54 user372 Note Added: 11001
2010-02-06 22:54 user372 Status assigned => feedback
2010-02-07 18:45 leolime File Added: limesurvey_sample_81995.csv
2010-02-10 08:19 leolime Note Added: 11025
2010-02-10 10:07 c_schmitz Note Added: 11029
2010-02-10 14:49 leolime File Added: ScreenShot014.jpg
2010-02-10 14:50 leolime File Added: ScreenShot015.jpg
2010-02-10 14:52 leolime Note Added: 11031
2010-03-09 21:00 c_schmitz Project Bug reports => Development
2010-03-09 21:00 c_schmitz Status feedback => assigned
2010-03-09 21:00 c_schmitz Assigned To user372 => c_schmitz
2010-05-14 14:06 Mazi Note Added: 11819
2010-05-14 14:07 Mazi Project Development => Bug reports
2010-05-14 14:07 Mazi Assigned To c_schmitz => texens
2010-05-16 00:35 texens Note Added: 11820
2010-05-16 00:35 texens Status assigned => confirmed
2010-05-16 00:35 texens File Added: bug04104-2.png
2010-05-16 12:50 Mazi Note Added: 11822
2010-05-16 15:31 texens Note Added: 11823
2010-05-16 16:34 Mazi Note Added: 11824
2010-05-17 10:36 leolime Note Added: 11826
2010-05-17 11:33 Mazi Note Added: 11828
2010-05-17 12:21 leolime Note Added: 11831
2010-05-17 12:37 Mazi Note Added: 11832
2010-05-22 21:53 texens File Added: bug-4104-other.png
2010-05-22 21:53 texens File Added: bug4104-other-details.png
2010-05-22 22:04 texens Note Added: 11946
2010-05-22 22:04 texens Status confirmed => resolved
2010-05-22 22:04 texens Resolution open => won't fix
2010-06-08 21:51 c_schmitz Status resolved => closed
2010-10-25 00:18 c_schmitz Category Survey at Runtime => Survey taking