|Anonymous | Login||2014-08-29 11:58 CEST|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap | Repositories|
|View Issue Details|
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|05068||Bug reports||[All Projects] Conditions||public||2011-03-31 17:08||2012-01-20 13:08|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version||1.92RC2|
|Summary||05068: Performance issue with long surveys and conditions|
|Description||When using conditions on a long survey and in the later of the course conditions are used then ALL previous values are embedded in the question page (in group by group mode) where any conditions are used. Naturally with a huge result set the page becomes pretty big AND slow.|
Could there be a 'smart' embedding so that only values are embedded in the page that are really used by the condition on that page?
|I will donate to the project if issue is resolved within 48 hrs||No|
|LimeSurvey build number OR git commit ID||1|
|Database & DB-Version||.|
|Operating System (Server)||.|
|Webserver software & version||.|
retrieveConditionInfo in qanda.php does a db query for every field, which could make things slow. Better would be to do 1 query, save the resulting array and filter out the qid you need by looping. This way a lot of db queries van be saved improving the speed.
To identify all the queries executed, edit the mysql to activate query log. This would be the best start I think as just inserting all fields should not be much of a problem.
It definately is a problem if there are 1000+ hidden fields in every page loaded.
Besides that it is a unnecessary waste of ressources.
I think long surveys and conditions have always been an issue and we did various things to improve speed in the past. Maybe we can use a survey from an old topic to check. I remember one that had many pages of arrays with filters that got slower and slower while you got more towards the end of the survey.
One recent thing added is using tokens in condition. If the problem survey doesn't use that, but does use tokens, it could be a nice start to rule out the newly added token feature by disabling tokens and seeing what performance does then.
|I did a fix to the array filter which caused a lot of unneeded repetition. Commited the fix in 9964 for bug 04787. Please check if this is still an issue.|
|Thomas, is this still an issue with the expresison engine?|
As to the database query issue, my hope is to see CreateFieldMap() re-designed to do a single DB query to popuplate everything $fieldmap('full') needs and store it in $_SESSION, including the answers.
EM will prevent the need for the long queries for getting Conditions, once we remove Conditions (or as long as people don't use them).
Lastly, for performance, we might want to add Relevance as a field in the Questions table so that I don't have to retrieve it from QuestionAttributes, but that isn't currently a problem, since we almost always have to get QuestionAttributes anyway, so I just create some relevance-related $_SESSION variables.
This is no longer an issue in 1.92.
Conditions are no longer read at run-time, so that slow-down is eliminated.
Although qanda does query the DB for every question (something that will be fixed in a plus release or 2.x), Conditions were the biggest source of slow-down.
|2011-03-31 17:08||c_schmitz||New Issue|
|2011-03-31 17:08||c_schmitz||Status||new => assigned|
|2011-03-31 17:08||c_schmitz||Assigned To||=> lemeur|
|2011-04-04 12:49||mdekker||Note Added: 14647|
|2011-04-04 12:51||c_schmitz||Note Added: 14649|
|2011-04-05 09:08||mdekker||Note Added: 14670|
|2011-04-05 09:11||mdekker||Relationship added||related to 04787|
|2011-04-05 13:35||mdekker||Note Added: 14673|
|2011-07-21 17:59||c_schmitz||Relationship added||has duplicate 05346|
|2011-09-11 10:03||c_schmitz||Assigned To||lemeur => TMSWhite|
|2011-09-11 10:03||c_schmitz||Note Added: 16258|
|2011-09-11 10:09||c_schmitz||Status||assigned => feedback|
|2011-09-11 14:58||TMSWhite||Note Added: 16266|
|2012-01-10 22:02||TMSWhite||Note Added: 16783|
|2012-01-10 22:02||TMSWhite||Status||feedback => resolved|
|2012-01-10 22:02||TMSWhite||Fixed in Version||=> 1.92RC1|
|2012-01-10 22:02||TMSWhite||Resolution||open => fixed|
|2012-01-20 13:07||c_schmitz||Fixed in Version||1.92RC1 => 1.92RC2|
|2012-01-20 13:08||c_schmitz||Note Added: 16841|
|2012-01-20 13:08||c_schmitz||Status||resolved => closed|
|Copyright © 2000 - 2014 MantisBT Team|